© 2003-2006 David Moles

Chrononautic Log

«  Further progress, with progress defined as “staying in one place and not moving”
  Main  
It’s on  »

art

This is what I get for not doing proper research

11 o'clock, February 22, 2006

Yes, it’s actual Islamic Amazons, among the Marsh Arabs, documented by Wilfred Thesiger four decades before I wrote “Planet of the Amazon Women.” Dammit.

In other news, I’ve sent my passport off to the consulate in Atlanta and should get it back today or tomorrow, with all appropriate stamps and attached paperwork. So maybe this Switzerland thing will actually happen.

Comments

that article was amazing.

—— Meghan, 12:29 PM, Wednesday, February 22, 2006

Wasn’t it? It’s learning stuff like that that makes me wonder if there isn’t some sort of massive global conspiracy to keep me ignorant.

—— David Moles, 8:03 AM, Thursday, February 23, 2006

I read about the Marsh Arabs a few years ago at National Geograhic, but they left out all the transgender stuff.

—— Greg van Eekhout, 10:16 AM, Thursday, February 23, 2006

That is too cool, and should be robbed for fiction.

As history, I'm slightly skeptical. Thesiger was not exactly a neutral observer, but someone with an intense, romantic, troubled, obsessive relationships with both gender and with pre-industrial societies (somewhat like the protagonist of POTAW). On the one hand, that's precisely the sort of person you'd expect to discover -- or even notice -- the Transgender Marsh Arabs Men Don't See. On the other hand, he was unbound by any academic oversight, peer review, stuff like that, and he might also have been the kind of guy who would make shit up because it sounded really cool.

cf:
http://www.glbtq.com/literature/thesiger_wp.html
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wilfred_Thesiger

Other societies with such sensible gender arrangements have been documented (in Polynesia, for instance), so I'm not skeptical in principle. I'd just like to see the report confirmed by someone other than Indiana Jones.

—— Benjamin Rosenbaum, 9:17 AM, Tuesday, February 28, 2006