© 2003-2006 David Moles

Chrononautic Log

«  Old news that maybe should be new again
  Main  
Funniest thing I hope never to see  »

economics

Allegory of the coastal town

10 o'clock, May 19, 2005

The sea level is rising. We all know this. Some day, maybe not this year, maybe not next year, but some day soon, in the lifetimes of many of us, the waves will overtop the sea wall, the dikes will burst, and our town, this beautiful town, once the wonder of the coast, will finally be swept away.

Some of us, the elders of the town, have lived here all their lives. They’ve seen the other coastal towns go under, one by one; they’ve traveled, some of them, to the rich inland cities and found no welcome there for our people. They are in no hurry to die, but if they must die, they would rather die here, in the town they helped build, the town where they once prospered, that has sheltered and supported them all their lives.

For others, the town’s young people, the town is already lost to us in our minds — not unmourned, not unregretted, but lost, nevertheless. We have known since we were children that it would be in our time that the ocean would come. We have never dreamed, as some of our elders have, that by some miracle the wonders of the old town would be restored. We have no wish to die here. We would rather build a new town on higher ground — smaller, no doubt; meaner, perhaps, by the standards of our elders; but a place where we can raise our children, and perhaps tell them stories of the grand coastal town that gave our people birth.

But now our elders would set us to filling sandbags, would take the timber we need to build our new town and use it to shore up the levees, would ask us to stand with them and plug the holes in the dikes with our fingers when we should be carrying our children to safety.

All to add a few more years to the life of the town that all of us, young people and elders alike, know cannot be saved.

Comments

I figure a raft village is our best bet.

—— Greg van Eekhout, 11:30 AM, Thursday, May 19, 2005

Raft village? Pshaw. Mutation followed by Patrick Duffy-like swimming.

—— Paul Melko, 11:38 AM, Thursday, May 19, 2005

Nah. Feels more like the emergence of a strongman from the younger members, who seizes control and forces a shift in strategy, or, failing a likely candidate for that role, most of the younger crowd simply disappearing in the night, leaving behind those unwilling to face reality.

—— Jon Hansen, 12:42 PM, Thursday, May 19, 2005

I was hoping we could amicably part ways, but slipping away in the night is starting to look like the best option.

With gills on.

—— David Moles, 12:44 PM, Thursday, May 19, 2005

What's all this crap about a smaller, meaner town? Just build it somewhere that will be oceanfront property when the dikes pop. Then invite in the tourists.

—— John Scalzi, 3:57 PM, Thursday, May 19, 2005

Y'know, I pointed the people talking about this stuff (well, actually, they're mainly talking about that brash young whippersnapper Corey Doctorow and his foolhardy attempts to destroy their livelihoods) over in the SFWA sff.net boards to this entry and to John Scalzi's entry from today. Not a bit of a response, as they glided right on past. Bizarre.

And speaking of Scalzi, I agree that the "smaller, meaner town" ain't right.

—— Christopher, 6:08 PM, Thursday, May 19, 2005

Well, actually I’m counting on glittering coral cities thronging with gorgeous mermaids (okay, and dashing mermen, too, let’s be fair) — but I didn’t want to get into that with the town elders, ’cause I know they’d never buy it.

—— David Moles, 7:42 AM, Friday, May 20, 2005

Wow. I just dropped over to the “Another Take on the Doctrow Thing” [sic] thread Raymond Feist started on sff.private.sfwa.lounge and now I feel like an anthropologist on Mars.

—— David Moles, 7:49 AM, Friday, May 20, 2005

OTOH, Wil McCarthy rocks. Maybe I should read his books. :)

—— David Moles, 7:55 AM, Friday, May 20, 2005

"Wow. I just dropped over to the “Another Take on the Doctrow Thing” [sic] thread Raymond Feist started on sff.private.sfwa.lounge and now I feel like an anthropologist on Mars.

What do you get when you cross a coelacanth with an ostrich?

—— Christopher, 10:46 AM, Friday, May 20, 2005

Actually, I think maybe you get two things: a smaller, meaner, uphill *town* -- and then the mutation with gills, and the vast, strange party under the sea.

And if we young bloods of the small town get together around the fireside in the meantime... well, you know, anthropologically, it's kind of _inevitable_ for us to whoop it up about how kick-ass it's going to be, and how our elders are just too timid to face the wave.

Do any of the rest of you, though, harbor secret doubts about how much we're going to like it out there among the coral?

To crosspost the relevant bit from my last missive to the sff.net group:

"But I will give you this -- I think most of us who are loudly proclaiming the coming digital era's transformation of the fiction landscape as an opportunity rather than a threat, and who embrace the "publish, then monetize" paradigm that the internet tends toward evolutionarily, are underestimating how easy it is, both in terms of marketing model and creative transformation. I think it's pretty telling that there are plenty of examples of webcomix artists and bloggers who have monetized the model successfully successfully, and few of novelists."

"I think I'm part of an generation uneasily caught in the middle -- who love the idea of one or another webby distribution model, but who sort of expect to ride the wave and end up writing the same sorts of stories and books that we grew up reading -- as if the forms of those stories and books weren't a direct consequence of the economic constraints and incentives of a previous era."

Sorry to be a downer. Pass the clams.

—— Benjamin Rosenbaum, 10:38 AM, Monday, May 23, 2005