I would SO buy this
2 o'clock, August 3, 2004
John Holbo has a suggestion:
[China] Miéville should seriously consider writing a thumping great historical political economy of his world – Marx’s Das Silmaril, if you will. It would be huge fun to read. It should be a multivolume affair that, ideally, he never manages to finish. (“What I have to examine is the magical mode of production, its supernatural laws and tendencies winning their way through and working themselves out with necessity as hard as mithril.” A long and careful analysis would follow of how power in Middle Earth is a function of — and race relations are inescapably mediated by — silmarills and, in later stages, ring ownership; value and use-value; importance of control of the means of ring production. “A spectre is haunting Middle Earth — no, really, a spectre!”)
Update: If you’re interested in epic fantasy — and when I say “interested in”, that includes “hostile to” — go and read the rest of his expanded post on Miéville. Post haste.
Or, for that matter, the other half of his conversation, over at Crooked Timber.
Iron Council should be arriving at my doorstep tomorrow. I can't wait.