© 2003-2006 David Moles

Chrononautic Log

«  Out of it
  Main  
Small gizmos, big arguments  »

economics

Delicate negotiations

12 o'clock, July 23, 2003

I am not discussing the moral correctness of blood money. This is the way things are done here and if this money will stop any sort of revenge killings then it is worth it. No, I only have one comment: being foreigners, they paid too much. Habibi, everything is bargainable here, and paying 15 million in blood money will ruin the blood money market — it is way too much. You should improve your tribal connections and get someone to bargain for you.

—— Salam Pax, writing in the Guardian

Comments

Like you, the concept of blood money makes me cringe. It should be pointed out that the sum was 15 million Iraqi dinars which converts to about $4,000. (Using Salam Pax's statement from before the war that the exchange rate hovering around 4000 dinars to the dollar.)

—— Scott Janssens, 12:59 PM, Wednesday, July 23, 2003

Actually, I’m not sure I’d go so far as to say “cringe”. I’m not advocating it, by any means, but considering the disagreements we have over the roles of restitution and retribution in our criminal justice system over here — not to mention wrongful death lawsuits and whatnot — it might be nice to have some kind of agreed-upon cultural framework for that sort of discussion, at least, if not a legal one.

Another context for looking at the amount is that Iraq’s prewar GDP per capita was about $2500.

—— David Moles, 1:09 PM, Wednesday, July 23, 2003

(I can’t tell how much of the article is tongue-in-cheek — it’s hard when the humor is, necessarily, so black.)

—— David Moles, 1:10 PM, Wednesday, July 23, 2003